One Tree Hill Season 4 Episode 5“I Love You But I've Chosen Darkness”

The CW · S4E5 · Aired October 25, 2006 · 60 min

When Lucas discovers that Derek's interest in Peyton is more than brotherly, Derek becomes menacing. Haley feels Nathan slipping away when he receives a scholarship offer to attend Duke University. As rumors of Brooke's pregnancy spread, Rachel uses the Internet to set Brooke up on a blind date with an older guy. At Nathan's request, Deb tries to kick her pill addiction.

Check off episodes as you watch and see when the next one is out. Free, no ads.